Review: The Quality of Mercy at the Courtyard Theatre

Theatre doesn’t get much more personal than this. The Quality of Mercy is the story of serial killer Harold Shipman, written and performed by Edwin Flay – a patient of Shipman’s as a child, and the grandson of Renee Lacey, who died at the Hyde GP’s hands when she was just 63 years old. Set in his cell on the night Shipman will take his own life, the play sees him recording a final tape, looking back on his life and crimes, and attempting to justify his motivation for ending so many innocent lives.

Photo credit: Anne Koerber

As one might expect, the story is chilling – not least because Shipman himself is, for the most part, icily calm and entirely confident in his own righteousness. He sneers at comparisons with other serial killers, believing himself to be driven by a higher purpose than their “sweaty id and uncontrollable lust”. And what’s terrifying is that to begin with, it almost makes sense; as we see Fred the helpless teenager watching his mother die slowly of cancer, and Shipman the charming young doctor treating a patient wracked with terrible pain, we can almost understand where that purpose might have come from. But as his crimes grow in number, it becomes apparent that he’s driven not by mercy but by ego, and the firm belief that only he should have the power to decide who lives and dies.

Despite Shipman’s obvious disdain for his victims – some of whom he openly admits he killed simply “to put them out of my misery” – the production treats them with infinite respect. As the play goes on, the names of his victims appear one by one on a large video screen at the back of the stage (credit to videographer Neil Monaghan), in a discreet but powerful tribute that also hammers home the shocking scale of Shipman’s crimes. Through flashbacks, we get glimpses of the man’s compassionate bedside manner and affable interactions with colleagues, which go some way to explaining how he could have got away with it for so long – but even so, that wall of over 200 names, and the knowledge that he could have been stopped so much earlier, is quietly devastating.

Photo credit: Anne Koerber

Director Bernie C. Byrnes’ production is simply staged, with the bed in Shipman’s cell doubling as a sick bed where many of his victims meet their end, while subtle changes in lighting and sound (Adam Bottomley and Kirsty Gillmore respectively) differentiate between present day and flashbacks. But what lifts the production to another level is Edwin Flay’s performance, which manages to be both persuasive and repellent all at once. There’s no doubt Shipman claimed to be fulfilling some divine purpose, but Flay’s portrayal exposes his true motivation in the rare moments where he loses control of his own narrative. These are moments of the blackest humour, but very telling – each time Shipman is forced to stop, take a breath and literally edit the record – and for that reason, those few moments wield the most power.

Though hardly a cheerful watch (but let’s face it, it was never going to be), ultimately The Quality of Mercy is true crime done right. There’s no attempt to glamorise Shipman’s crimes, or even – perhaps despite first appearances – justify them. In the end the focus, rightly, is on his victims, and ultimately in the coming days, weeks and months, that wall of names is what I’ll remember.

The Quality of Mercy continues at the Courtyard Theatre until 8th October.

Quick Q&A: The Quality of Mercy

Where and when: The Courtyard Theatre in Hoxton – 27 September – 8 October, Tuesday – Saturday at 7pm plus 2.30pm on Saturdays

What it’s all about… In his cell in the dead of night, Dr Harold Shipman sits and records a confessional tape, tracing his journey from childhood to becoming the most prolific serial killer in British history.

You’ll like it if… you’re interested in true crime, biographical theatre, or an in-depth psychological study of a murderer whose motives will forever remain shrouded in mystery. Beyond the central character, The Quality of Mercy touches on themes of euthanasia, narcissistic psychopathy, and how the human desire to see justice done can often become warped into a lust for power.

You should see it because… It’s really good! Seriously, it’s been meticulously researched with a central performance that will make you sit bolt upright in your seat. Media about crime in general, and murder in particular, tends to be sensationalist and even lurid; from the beginning, we’ve conceived this piece to be thrilling, but profoundly respectful to the victims and their families.

Anything else we should know… Edwin Flay, the playwright and actor, is related to one of Shipman’s victims, and he was himself a patient of Shipman’s as a small boy. He wrote this in 2019, in part in response to conversations he had about Shipman, in which people seemed to have forgotten the extent of the man’s crimes. The Quality of Mercy has been published by PlayDead Press, and will be available for purchase at the show.

Where to follow:
Twitter: @NailedCreates @CourtyardHoxton @EdwinFlay @La_Lawrie @BernieCByrnes #QualityofMercyPlay

Instagram: @CourtyardTheatre @La_Lawrie @BernieC.Byrnes #QualityofMercyPlay

Ticket link:

Review: Another Eavesdropping at the Jack Studio Theatre

We all love a bit of eavesdropping – whether it’s just a single line heard out of context, or a complete story, overheard conversations can give us an insight into the world and the people around us, inspire flights of imagination, and spark new discussions of our own. Angel Theatre clearly see the dramatic potential of listening in to these encounters, as they return with Another Eavesdropping, which follows previous productions EavesdroppingMore Eavesdropping and Eavesdropping Again.

Photo credit: Angel Theatre

To create Another Eavesdropping, the cast of twelve (Ben Armitage, Anna Bonnett, Georgia Dawson, Kieran Dooner, Kitty Evans, Beatrice Hyde, Gordana Kostic, James Lee, Taylor Pope, Laura Shipler Chico, Christie Silvester and Ricky Zalman) spent several weeks transcribing genuine conversations they overheard while out in public. Each transcription was anonymised and the raw text shared with the rest of the company to be adapted into a short scene. Some of these scenes are funny, some heartbreaking, some confusing, and some extremely mundane – just like real life. Because the words are presented verbatim, there’s no perfectly crafted script or carefully designed narrative arc; some get surprisingly deep with very few words, while others become repetitive to the point of absurdity and ultimately end up saying very little. Some of the characters are instantly sympathetic, while others are harder to like – but each of them has something to say, and that’s the key point.

Because the show is made up of lots of completely individual vignettes, there’s no plot to connect them, but the cast do a good job of transitioning smoothly from one to the next so that the show rarely feels disjointed. When not performing in a scene, the actors all sit motionless at the side, impassively observing the action. A shelf unit at the back of the stage contains a number of props – a shopping bag, a bowl of pasta, an apple, a book, some yoga mats… – each of which plays a key role in a single scene. The settings for each piece have been selected by the cast, the real setting never having been shared with the rest of the company, and throughout the evening we find ourselves in a golf club, on a bus, in a pharmacy, and any number of everyday locations. As a result, we get to hear from a decent range of voices, although a lack of diversity among the cast means this doesn’t go as far as it could, and the London life portrayed in the show is probably not one that everyone will recognise.

Photo credit: Angel Theatre

The idea of Another Eavesdropping is a clever one, with an infinite supply of new material to be had – you only have to step out your front door, get on a bus or go to the shops to overhear any number of similar conversations on any given day. The key ingredient here is not the words themselves but how they’re brought to life, and strong performances and an ear for the often unintentional humour that’s all around us is what makes Another Eavesdropping an enjoyable show to watch. It might also make you think twice before you start another public conversation, as you never know who might be listening…

Another Eavesdropping continues at the Jack Studio Theatre until 1st October.

Quick Q&A: The Valley of Fear

Where and when: UK Tour, 21 September – 23 March

What it’s all about… The Valley of Fear begins with Sherlock Holmes receiving a coded message from a secret informant he has embedded in the crime world, warning him of an imminent threat to someone at a manor house in Sussex. Within moments of receiving this, the news comes of a murder. Holmes and Watson travel down to investigate the strange circumstances of the murder, and in doing so, unravel a mystery that takes us to the USA and back again, and with a rather sinister figure at its centre.

You’ll like it if… I think this is a show for everyone. If you are a Holmes fan, you’ll love this show. It’s true to the book, but with some brilliant additions by Nick Lane to bring out all the tension and backstory of the drama. If you’ve never read or seen a Holmes story before, and you just love good theatre, this is also the play for you. It has compelling characters, a really brilliant mystery, murder, a love story, action, live music and will take you on a hell of an adventure.

You should see it because… Well, this is a Sherlock Holmes story, so it’s written for everyone. Conan Doyle’s instalments of the stories in the Strand magazine were the popular culture highlight of the day, among those who enjoyed them. I always think that Victorian audiences must have had to struggle through the agonising wait of weekly instalments of the stories in just the same way we have to with great TV series today. So this is a show for those who love Holmes stories, but also any lovers of murder mysteries, suspense and adventure. If you came to see the last Blackeyed Theatre Holmes production, The Sign of Four, we have the same Holmes and Watson back on stage, so we see a new aspect of their friendship. I think audiences will see new challenges for the duo, their friendship and working relationship, and how they must overcome these as well as the complexities of the mystery.

Where to follow:
Twitter: @Blackeyedtheatr

Ticket link:

Review: Landscape with Weapon at the Cockpit Theatre

It’s every inventor’s worst nightmare: the idea that their creation could fall into the wrong hands. And if that creation is then used to cause harm, how much responsibility should the inventor be expected to bear for the consequences?

This is the central question of Joe Penhall’s Landscape with Weapon, first seen in 2007 and now revived by director Jason Moore of Onbook Theatre. Ned (Danny Szam) is a self-styled “mad genius” who’s come up with a new military technology that he believes will reduce civilian casualties through its deadly accuracy. But as he comes under pressure to sign a government contract and relinquish the intellectual property behind his invention, Ned starts – somewhat belatedly, you could argue – to worry about the possible implications.

Photo credit: Giacomo Giannelli

That moment of realisation comes after discussions with his brother, Dan (James Robinson), a dentist who seemingly has everything Ned doesn’t – the wife, the kids, the mortgage. With a bit of persuasion, and despite having signed the Official Secrets Act, Ned reveals to his brother what he’s been working on, and the moral high ground shifts rapidly as Dan – who just moments before was bragging about the ethically dubious sideline in botox that’s about to pay for his new swimming pool – reacts with instant horror. Even then, Ned sticks to his guns, stubbornly insisting that because his own intentions are honourable, any unintended consequences of letting his invention out into the world can hardly be pinned on him. And herein lies the play’s biggest flaw: while his viewpoint might be reasonable if he’d invented something inherently innocuous, Ned’s about to sell weapon technology to the Ministry of Defence, and his lack of foresight is at best unrealistic, at worst downright alarming. Considering how many times we’re reminded of the character’s intelligence, it’s difficult to believe he’d never before considered any of the qualms that become so important to him in Act 2.

That aside, the stage is now set for an interesting and often topical debate, and it’s presented by a strong cast, who do their best with some at times unnecessarily dense material. Commercial director Ross (Suzy Bloom) tries every trick in the book to convince Ned to sign, but their conversations go so deeply into the ins and outs of government business contracts, controlling shares and intellectual property law that it can be difficult to stay focused. The Act 2 arrival of sinister intelligence man Brooks (Malcolm Jeffries) takes us in a slightly different direction and raises the tension nicely, before a late twist in the tale sets the stage for a dramatic finale that never quite comes to pass. That said, the play’s deliberately muted and open-ended conclusion is, in its own way, quite haunting.

Photo credit: Giacomo Giannelli

Set designer Ian Nicholas largely lets the script do the talking, with the action taking place on a minimally furnished stage covered in inventor’s scribbles. There’s some great work too from Jonny Danciger, whose effortlessly naturalistic sound effects (including a rather too convincing off-stage bathroom visit) give way to total silence in Act 2 as the suspense begins to build.

Though not without its flaws, Landscape with Weapon asks some interesting and uncomfortable questions, and ultimately proves that when it comes to morality, right and wrong are not always as clear-cut as we might like them to be.

Landscape with Weapon is at the Cockpit Theatre until 18th September.